Home › Blog › Christmas puzzle books
Christmas is the biggest puzzle book season and the most crowded. The advantage goes almost entirely to whoever published early, so this is the one worth planning first.
Christmas is the largest seasonal market for puzzle books and by far the most competitive. The listings at the top are usually not the best books; they are the books that have been on sale longest, with the most reviews and the deepest sales history.
That has one practical consequence: publishing date beats almost everything else you can control. A good book live in September will generally outperform a better book live in November.
| By this point | What needs to be done |
|---|---|
| August | Interior built, cover designed |
| Early September | Physical proof ordered and checked |
| End of September | Live on Amazon |
| October | Listing indexes; gift-shopping searches begin |
| Late November to mid December | The main selling window |
Christmas is the secular vocabulary — reindeer, tinsel, stockings, eggnog. The Christmas Story is the nativity, which suits church groups and faith-based gift books and competes in a much thinner category. Winter Wonderland avoids the holiday entirely, so a book built on it keeps selling through January and February rather than dying on 26 December. New Year's Eve extends the same run by another few weeks.
Christmas listings collapse the day after Christmas. Winter-themed books do not, because the weather does not stop in December. A winter title published alongside a Christmas one shares the same production work and keeps earning for two more months.
You cannot manufacture listing age, so the things left to compete on are format and correctness:
PuzzleBindery verifies every sudoku has exactly one solution and every maze exactly one path before it renders, and it assembles the solutions section from the puzzles it actually placed, so the answer key cannot fall out of step with the book.
The interior and full wrap cover are generated together, with the spine measured from the live page count. Building and previewing is free; you pay once when you want to publish.
By the end of September, and earlier is better. Christmas shopping searches begin in earnest in October and peak through the first half of December, so a listing needs to be indexed and gathering signals well before that.
A November listing can still catch late shoppers, but it is competing against titles with a year or more of ranking history. Publishing anyway is usually still worthwhile, because the book starts the following season already established.
There is no required number. What matters more is that the page count is even, the gutter matches the final count, and the solutions are complete. A tight 50-puzzle book with correct print settings outperforms a padded one that gets returned.